College Sports Communicators (formerly CoSIDA: College Sports Information Directors of America) has recognized academic achievement in collegiate athletics since 1952 with its Academic All-America® program. Below is a sport-by-sport listing of St. Mary's University Academic All-Americans.
   

Baseball
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2002-2003	Brandon Roznovsky	2nd
2012-2013	Carl O'Neal	1st
2013-2014	Rene Solis	3rd

  

Men's Golf
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2025-2026	Kongpop Kaikaew	3rd

 

Women's Golf
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2023-2024	Libby Kilbride	2nd
2023-2024	Rebecca Reed	1st
2024-2025	Libby Kilbride	1st

 

Men's Soccer
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2023-2024	Cian Foley	2nd

   

Softball
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2014-15	Haley Richter	3rd

 

Men's Tennis
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2015-2016	Michael Maciel	2nd
2024-2025	Alvaro Soler	3rd

 

Women's Tennis
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2013-2014	Mariana Rong	3rd
2014-2015	Cristina Lopez	3rd
2014-2015	Mariana Rong	1st
2015-2016	Jamie Lee Denton	2nd
2015-2016	Cristina Lopez	2nd
2017-2018	Kaylin Kruseman	1st