Below is a sport-by-sport listing of St. Mary's University All-Americans.
   

Baseball
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
1960	Bill Sebera Jr.	NAIA 1st
1963	Ken Collins	NAIA 1st
1966	Bill Grabarkewitz	NAIA 1st
1968	Ronnie Newman	NAIA HM
1970	Charles Rother	NAIA HM
1970	Wes Skidmore	NAIA HM
1970	Jimmy Wolfe	NAIA 1st
1976	Danny Heep	NAIA 1st
1976	Ted Trevino	NAIA HM
1976	Glynn Tschirhart	NAIA HM
1977	Danny Heep	NAIA HM
1977	Charlie Migl	NAIA HM
1978	Danny Heep	NAIA HM
1983	Mark Bond	NAIA HM
1986	Jimmy Garcia	NAIA HM
1987	Steve Carrasco	NAIA HM
1987	Jimmy Garcia	NAIA HM
1987	Steve Keller	NAIA 1st
1989	Mark Christian	NAIA HM
1989	Brian Davenport	NAIA HM
1992	Pete Magre	NAIA HM
1992	Craig Navarijo	NAIA HM
1993	Neil Atkinson	NAIA 1st
1993	Derrick Dietrich	NAIA 1st
1995	Jeff Kubenka	NAIA 1st
1995	Rodney Williams	NAIA HM
1996	Aaron Carter	NAIA 1st
1996	Jeff Kubenka	NAIA HM
1998	Eric Battersby	NAIA 1st
1998	Randy Socha	NAIA HM
1998	Pete Villanueva	NAIA HM
1999	Jeff Appelt	NAIA HM
2001	Jesse Gutierrez	ABCA 1st
2001	O.J. Garza	ABCA 2nd
2003	Ryan Hill	ABCA 3rd
2004	Jeff Wigdahl	ABCA 3rd
2007	Michael Brzezinski	NCBWA HM
2008	Scott Shimek	ABCA HM
2011	Sammy Rivas	Daktronics 2nd
2012	M.P. Cokinos	Daktronics 3rd
2012	Carl O'Neal	ABCA 1st, NCBWA 1st, Daktronics 1st
2012	Rene Solis	Daktronics 2nd
2013	Carl O'Neal	ABCA 2nd, NCBWA 2nd, Daktronics 2nd
2013	Jonathan Perez	NCBWA HM
2014	Rene Solis	NCBWA HM
2015	Matt McClain	ABCA 3rd, NCBWA HM

 

Men's Basketball
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
1963-64	Ken Sampson	NAIA 3rd
1964-65	Buddy Meyer	NAIA HM
1966-67	Doug Williams	NAIA 3rd
1967-68	Doug Williams	NAIA 2nd
1968-69	Jim Wehman	NAIA HM
1969-70	Doug Williams	NAIA 1st
1972-73	Gary Tomaszewski	NAIA 1st
1972-73	Don Wesley	NAIA HM
1974-75	Gary Tomaszewski	NAIA 1st
1974-75	Robert Reid	NAIA HM
1975-76	Robert Reid	NAIA 2nd
1976-77	Robert Reid	NAIA 1st
1977-78	Leon Walls	NAIA HM
1978-79	Leon Walls	NAIA HM
1980-81	Ricky Hooker	NAIA 1st
1981-82	Ricky Hooker	NAIA 1st
1982-83	Ricky Hooker	NAIA 1st
1982-83	Jai Mahone	NAIA HM
1982-83	Gary Gaspard	NAIA HM
1983-84	Melvin Roseboro	NAIA 2nd
1984-85	Kenneth Cook	NAIA HM
1986-87	Peter Hansen	NAIA HM
1988-89	Anthony Houston	NAIA 1st
1989-90	Rudy Archer	NAIA HM
1990-91	Gabe Ramirez	NAIA 1st
1990-91	Steve O'Keefe	NAIA HM
1991-92	Elliot Henderson	NAIA HM
1991-92	Gabe Ramirez	NAIA HM
1992-93	Elliot Henderson	NAIA HM
1993-94	Erik Coleman	NAIA HM
1993-94	Chris LeGrand	NAIA HM
1994-95	Chris LeGrand	NAIA 3rd
1995-96	Tyrell Whisenton	NAIA 1st
1996-97	Lacy Hampton	NAIA HM
1996-97	Tyrell Whisenton	NAIA HM
1997-98	Dayo Holloway	NAIA HM
1997-98	David Ricks	NAIA HM
1998-99	Lacy Hampton	NAIA HM
1998-99	Miles Parks	NAIA HM
2012-13	Kevin Kotzur	Daktronics 1st, DII Bulleton 2nd

 

Women's Basketball
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
1982-1983	Mary Hoernschemeyer	WBCA HM
1987-1988	Yvette Buentello	WBCA HM
1994-1995	Julie Lynch	WBCA HM
1995-1996	Betsy Powers	WBCA HM
1996-1997	Laura Walker	Kodak 1st, WBCA 2nd
2001-2002	Erin Griffin	Kodak 1st, WBCA 1st
2002-2003	Erin Griffin	WBCA HM
2008-2009	Natalie Gamez	WBCA HM
2012-2013	Jackie Woods	WBCA HM
2014-2015	Morgan Pullins	Daktronics 1st, BennettRank.com D2 2nd, WBCA HM
2016-2017	Kiara Etheridge	WBCA HM
2019-2020	Soteria Banks	WBCA HM

 

Men's Golf
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
1994-95	Robert McVeigh	GCAA 1st
2002-03	Luke Antonelli	GCAA HM
2003-04	Luke Antonelli	GCAA 1st
2005-06	Jamie Amoretti	GCAA 1st
2006-07	Jamie Amoretti	GCAA HM
2007-08	Matt Vela	GCAA HM
2009-10	Matt Vela	GCAA 2nd
2017-18	Emilio Gonzalez	GCAA 1st
2018-19	Emilio Gonzalez	GCAA 3rd
2019-20	Ryan Dixon	GCAA HM
2019-20	Emilio Gonzalez	GCAA 1st
2021-22	Ryan Dixon	GCAA HM
2024-25	Guillaume Paquette	GCAA HM
2024-25	Baptiste Touchard	GCAA 3rd
2025-26	Kongpop Kaikaew	GCAA 3rd

 

Women's Golf
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2001-02	Jillian Wyne	WGCA 2nd
2002-03	Jillian Wyne	WGCA 1st
2003-04	Marla Troester	WGCA HM
2003-04	Nicole Wyne	WGCA HM
2006-07	Jessica Harbin	WGCA 2nd
2015-16	Kelly Contreras	WGCA HM
2016-17	Maria Regina Gonzalez	WGCA HM
2017-18	Maria Regina Gonzalez	WGCA 2nd
2017-18	Kelly Contreras	WGCA HM
2018-19	Maria Regina Gonzalez	WGCA 1st
2020-21	Estelle Beck	WGCA HM
2020-21	Monica Dibildox	WGCA 2nd
2020-21	Sofia Ruescas	WGCA HM
2023-24	Savannah Dupre	WGCA HM
2023-24	Libby Kilbride	WGCA HM
2023-24	Rebecca Reed	WGCA 2nd
2024-25	Savannah Dupre	WGCA 1st
2024-25	Libby Kilbride	WGCA HM
2025-26	Taylor Wilczek	WGCA 1st

 

Men's Soccer
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
1982	Marty Buckley	NAIA 1st
1997	Anh Tran	NAIA 1st
1997	Que Willis	NAIA 1st
1998	Que Willis	NAIA HM
2018	Pato Botello Faz	D2CCA 2nd
2019	Ollie Wright	USC 1st, D2CCA 3rd
2022	Ariel Cardozo	USC 2nd
2022	Lewis Wilson	D2CCA 1st, USC 2nd

 

Women's Soccer
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
1994	Katie Quathamer	NAIA 1st
1997	Kelly Shaughnessy	NAIA 1st
1998	Rachel Major	NAIA 3rd
2023	Shelby Paniagua	D2CCA 2nd

 

Softball
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
1983	Terri Nunez	NAIA 2nd
1985	Leticia Morales	NAIA 1st
1986	Mary Kalinec	NAIA 1st
1986	Leticia Morales	NAIA 2nd
1987	Donna Eckert	NAIA 1st
1987	Adrian Jonietz	NAIA 2nd
1988	Adrian Jonietz	NAIA 2nd
1988	Jennifer Zapalac	NAIA 2nd
1989	Adrian Jonietz	NAIA 1st
1989	Jennifer Zapalac	NAIA 1st
1990	Jennifer Zapalac	NAIA 2nd
1991	Monique Fluellen	NAIA 2nd
1991	Lana Rutledge	NAIA 1st
1991	Jennifer Zapalac	NAIA 2nd
1992	Monique Fluellen	NAIA 1st
1992	Shannon Tigner	NAIA 2nd
1993	Monique Fluellen	NAIA 1st
1993	Aimee Silva	NAIA 1st
1994	Monique Fluellen	NAIA 1st
1994	Aimee Silva	NAIA 1st
1995	Sue Urbanovsky	NAIA 2nd
1996	Kelli Smith	NAIA 1st
1997	Janelle Carrington	NAIA 2nd
1997	Jamie Kemper	NAIA 1st
1997	Kelli Smith	NAIA 2nd
1997	Lynne Sustala	NAIA 1st
2000	Elizabeth Card	NFCA 3rd
2002	Natalie Hill	NFCA 1st
2002	Kym Kling	NFCA 1st
2003	Roni Garcia	NFCA 2nd
2003	Kym Kling	NFCA 1st
2003	Jennifer Survant	NFCA 3rd
2004	Elizabeth Beyer	NFCA 1st
2004	Roni Garcia	NFCA 2nd
2004	Kym Kling	NFCA 2nd
2005	Elizabeth Beyer	NFCA 1st
2005	Tiffani Craft	NFCA 2nd
2005	Roni Garcia	NFCA 1st
2005	Malissa Magee	NFCA 3rd
2007	Malissa Magee	NFCA 2nd
2007	Kelcy Walker	NFCA 2nd
2008	Malissa Magee	NFCA 2nd, Daktronics 3rd
2009	Arlynda Flores	NFCA 1st, Daktronics 1st
2011	Jared Gonzalez	Daktronics HM
2013	Emily Brittain	Daktronics HM
2014	Emily Brittain	Daktronics HM
2015	Nicole Sardelich	Daktronics 2nd, NFCA 3rd
2015	Vianna Gutierrez-Touchtone	NFCA 2nd, Daktronics 3rd
2015	Taylor Vidrine	Daktronics HM
2016	Sydney Wellmann	NFCA 3rd, Daktronics 3rd

 

STUNT
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2023	Alecka Brown	CSCA HM
2023	Sanaa Johnson	CSCA 2nd
2023	Yanelle Nicholson	CSCA 1st
2024	Alecka Brown	CSCA 1st
2024	Courtney McClellan	CSCA HM
2024	Isabel Soto	CSCA 2nd
2025	Alecka Brown	CSCA HM

 

Men's Tennis
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2017-18	Jeremiah Sanchez	ITA 1st (singles & doubles)
2017-18	Bojan Popovic	ITA 1st (doubles)
2019-20	Brendan Brown	ITA 1st (doubles)
2019-20	Jeremiah Sanchez	ITA 1st (doubles)
2020-21	Jeremiah Sanchez	ITA 1st (singles)

 

Women's Tennis
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
2012-13	Mariana Rong	ITA 1st (singles)
2014-15	Cristina Lopez	ITA 1st (doubles)
2014-15	Mariana Rong	ITA 1st (doubles)
2016-17	Kaylin Kruseman	ITA 1st (doubles)
2016-17	Tyra Timm	ITA 1st (doubles)
2017-18	Kaylin Kruseman	ITA 1st (singles & doubles)
2017-18	Tyra Timm	ITA 1st (doubles)
2019-20	Ashley Penshorn	ITA 1st (singles & doubles)
2019-20	Marina Vigil	ITA 1st (doubles)
2022-23	Ashley Penshorn	ITA 1st (singles)

 

Volleyball
Year	Student-Athlete Name	Team(s)
1993	April Fricke	NAIA 2nd
1994	Ginger Grimes	NAIA 1st
1995	Ginger Grimes	NAIA 3rd
1995	Kathryn McCarthy	NAIA 1st
1996	Ginger Grimes	NAIA 1st
1996	Leslie Stults	NAIA HM
1997	J.J. Johnson	NAIA HM
1997	Leslie Stults	NAIA 3rd
1998	Katie Griffin	NAIA HM
2006	Samantha Weber	AVCA HM