Listed below are the 200 student-athletes who have been awarded All-American distinction in St. Mary's proud history.
 

Year	Sport	Name	Team
1960	Baseball	Bill Sebera Jr.	1st
1963	Baseball	Ken Collins	1st
1963-64	Men's Basketball	Ken Sampson	3rd
1964-65	Men's Basketball	Buddy Meyer	HM
1966	Baseball	Bill Grabarkewitz	1st
1966-67	Men's Basketball	Doug Williams	3rd
1967-68	Men's Basketball	Doug Williams	2nd
1968	Baseball	Ronnie Newman	HM
1968-69	Men's Basketball	Jim Wehman	HM
1969-70	Men's Basketball	Doug Williams	1st
1970	Baseball	Charles Rother	HM
1970	Baseball	Wes Skidmore	HM
1970	Baseball	Jimmy Wolfe	1st
1972-73	Men's Basketball	Gary Tomaszewski	1st
1972-73	Men's Basketball	Don Wesley	HM
1974-75	Men's Basketball	Gary Tomaszewski	1st
1974-75	Men's Basketball	Robert Reid	HM
1975-76	Men's Basketball	Robert Reid	2nd
1976	Baseball	Danny Heep	1st
1976	Baseball	Ted Trevino	HM
1976	Baseball	Glynn Tschirhart	HM
1976-77	Men's Basketball	Robert Reid	1st
1977	Baseball	Danny Heep	HM
1977	Baseball	Charlie Migl	HM
1977-78	Men's Basketball	Leon Walls	HM
1978	Baseball	Danny Heep	HM
1978-79	Men's Basketball	Leon Walls	HM
1980-81	Men's Basketball	Ricky Hooker	1st
1981-82	Men's Basketball	Ricky Hooker	1st
1982	Men's Soccer	Marty Buckley	1st
1982-83	Men's Basketball	Ricky Hooker	1st
1982-83	Men's Basketball	Jai Mahone	HM
1982-83	Men's Basketball	Gary Gaspard	HM
1982-83	Women's Basketball	Mary Hoernschemeyer	HM
1983	Baseball	Mark Bond	HM
1983	Softball	Terri Nunez	2nd
1983-84	Men's Basketball	Melvin Roseboro	2nd
1984-85	Men's Basketball	Kenneth Cook	HM
1985	Softball	Leticia Morales	1st
1986	Baseball	Jimmy Garcia	HM
1986	Softball	Donna Fields	1st
1986	Softball	Mary Kalinec	1st
1986	Softball	Leticia Morales	2nd
1986-87	Men's Basketball	Peter Hansen	HM
1987	Baseball	Steve Carrasco	HM
1987	Baseball	Jimmy Garcia	HM
1987	Baseball	Steve Keller	1st
1987	Softball	Adrian Jonietz	2nd
1987-88	Women's Basketball	Yvette Buentello	HM
1988	Softball	Adrian Jonietz	2nd
1988	Softball	Jennifer Zapalac	2nd
1988-89	Men's Basketball	Anthony Houston	1st
1989	Baseball	Mark Christian	HM
1989	Baseball	Brian Davenport	HM
1989	Softball	Adrian Jonietz	1st
1989	Softball	Jennifer Zapalac	1st
1989-90	Men's Basketball	Rudy Archer	HM
1990	Softball	Jennifer Zapalac	2nd
1990-91	Men's Basketball	Gabe Ramirez	1st
1990-91	Men's Basketball	Steve O'Keefe	HM
1991	Softball	Monique Fluellen	2nd
1991	Softball	Lana Rutledge	1st
1991	Softball	Jennifer Zapalac	2nd
1991-92	Men's Basketball	Elliot Henderson	HM
1991-92	Men's Basketball	Gabe Ramirez	HM
1992	Baseball	Pete Magre	HM
1992	Baseball	Craig Navarijo	HM
1992	Softball	Monique Fluellen	2nd
1992	Softball	Aimee Silva	1st
1992-93	Men's Basketball	Elliot Henderson	HM
1993	Baseball	Neil Atkinson	1st
1993	Baseball	Derrick Dietrich	1st
1993	Softball	Monique Fluellen	1st
1993	Softball	Aimee Silva	1st
1993	Volleyball	April Fricke	2nd
1993-94	Men's Basketball	Erik Coleman	HM
1993-94	Men's Basketball	Chris LeGrand	HM
1994	Softball	Monique Fluellen	1st
1994	Softball	Aimee Silva	1st
1994	Volleyball	Ginger Grimes	1st
1994	Women's Soccer	Katie Quathamer	1st
1994-95	Men's Basketball	Chris LeGrand	3rd
1994-95	Women's Basketball	Julie Lynch	HM
1995	Baseball	Jeff Kubenka	1st
1995	Baseball	Rodney Williams	HM
1995	Men's Golf	Robert McVeigh	1st
1995	Softball	Sue Urbanovsky	2nd
1995	Volleyball	Ginger Grimes	3rd
1995	Volleyball	Kathryn McCarthy	1st
1995-96	Men's Basketball	Tyrell Whisenton	1st
1995-96	Women's Basketball	Betsy Powers	HM
1996	Baseball	Aaron Carter	1st
1996	Baseball	Jeff Kubenka	HM
1996	Softball	Kerry Keegan	1st
1996	Softball	Megan Mertins	3rd
1996	Volleyball	Ginger Grimes	1st
1996	Volleyball	Leslie Stults	HM
1996-97	Men's Basketball	Lacy Hampton	HM
1996-97	Men's Basketball	Tyrell Whisenton	HM
1996-97	Women's Basketball	Laura Walker	1st 2nd
1997	Softball	Janelle Carrington	2nd
1997	Softball	Kelli Smith	2nd
1997	Men's Soccer	Que Willis	1st
1997	Men's Soccer	Anh Tran	1st
1997	Volleyball	J.J. Johnson	HM
1997	Volleyball	Leslie Stults	3rd
1997	Women's Soccer	Kelly Shaughnessy	1st
1997-98	Men's Basketball	Dayo Holloway	HM
1997-98	Men's Basketball	David Ricks	HM
1998	Baseball	Eric Battersby	1st
1998	Baseball	Randy Socha	HM
1998	Baseball	Pete Villanueva	HM
1998	Men's Soccer	Que Willis	HM
1998	Women's Soccer	Rachel Major	3rd
1998	Volleyball	Katie Griffin	HM
1998-99	Men's Basketball	Lacy Hampton	HM
1998-99	Men's Basketball	Miles Parks	HM
1999	Baseball	Jeff Appelt	HM
2001	Baseball	Jesse Gutierrez	1st
2001	Baseball	O.J. Garza	2nd
2001-02	Women's Basketball	Erin Griffin	1st
2002	Women's Golf	Jillian Wyne	2nd
2002	Softball	Natalie Hill	1st
2002	Softball	Kym Kling	1st
2002-03	Women's Basketball	Erin Griffin	HM
2003	Men's Golf	Luke Antonelli	HM
2003	Women's Golf	Jillian Wyne	1st
2003	Baseball	Ryan Hill	3rd
2003	Softball	Veronica Garcia	2nd
2003	Softball	Kym Kling	1st
2003	Softball	Jennifer Survant	3rd
2004	Men's Golf	Luke Antonelli	1st
2004	Women's Golf	Marla Troester	HM
2004	Women's Golf	Nicole Wyne	HM
2004	Baseball	Jeff Wigdahl	3rd
2004	Softball	Elizabeth Beyer	1st
2004	Softball	Veronica Garcia	1st
2004	Softball	Kym Kling	1st
2005	Softball	Elizabeth Beyer	1st
2005	Softball	Tiffani Craft	2nd
2005	Softball	Veronica Garcia	1st
2005	Softball	Malissa Magee	3rd
2006	Men's Golf	Jamie Amoretti	1st
2006	Volleyball	Samantha Weber	HM
2007	Baseball	Michael Brzezinski	HM
2007	Men's Golf	Jamie Amoretti	HM
2007	Women's Golf	Jessica Harbin	2nd
2007	Softball	Malissa Magee	2nd
2007	Softball	Kelcy Walker	2nd
2008	Men's Golf	Matt Vela	HM
2008	Baseball	Scott Shimek	HM
2008	Softball	Malissa Magee	2nd 3rd
2008-09	Women's Basketball	Natalie Gamez	HM
2009	Softball	Arlynda Flores	1st
2011	Softball	Jared Gonzalez	HM
2011	Baseball	Sammy Rivas	HM
2012	Baseball	M.P. Cokinos	3rd
2012	Baseball	Carl O'Neal	1st
2012	Baseball	Rene Solis	2nd
2012-13	Men's Basketball	Kevin Kotzur	1st
2012-13	Women's Basketball	Jackie Woods	HM
2013	Softball	Emily Brittain	HM
2013	Baseball	Carl O'Neal	2nd
2013	Baseball	Jonathan Perez	HM
2013	Women's Tennis	Mariana Rong	1st
2014	Softball	Emily Brittain	HM
2014	Baseball	Rene Solis	HM
2014-15	Women's Basketball	Morgan Pullins	1st
2014-15	Women's Tennis	Mariana Rong	1st
2014-15	Women's Tennis	Cristina Lopez	1st
2015	Softball	Vianna Gutierrez Touchtone	2nd
2015	Softball	Nicole Sardelich	2nd
2015	Softball	Taylor Vidrine	HM
2015	Baseball	Matt McClain	3rd
2016	Women's Golf	Kelly Contreras	HM
2016	Softball	Sydney Wellmann	3rd
2016-17	Women's Basketball	Kiara Etheridge	HM
2016-17	Women's Golf	Maria Regina Gonzalez	HM
2016-17	Women's Tennis	Kaylin Kruseman	1st
2016-17	Women's Tennis	Tyra Timm	1st
2017-18	Men's Golf	Emilio Gonzalez	1st
2017-18	Women's Golf	Maria Regina Gonzalez	2nd
2017-18	Women's Golf	Kelly Contreras	HM
2017-18	Men's Tennis	Jeremiah Gonzalez (singles)	1st
2017-18	Men's Tennis	Jeremiah Gonzalez (doubles)	1st
2017-18	Men's Tennis	Bojan Popovic	1st
2017-18	Women's Tennis	Kaylin Kruseman (singles)	1st
2017-18	Women's Tennis	Kaylin Kruseman (doubles)	1st
2017-18	Women's Tennis	Tyra Timm	1st
2018-19	Men's Soccer	Pato Botello Faz	2nd
2018-19	Men's Golf	Emilio Gonzalez	3rd
2018-19	Women's Golf	Maria Regina Gonzalez	1st
2019-20	Women's Basketball	Soteria Banks	HM
2019-20	Men's Golf	Ryan Dixon	HM
2019-20	Men's Golf	Emilio Gonzalez	1st
2019-20	Men's Soccer	Ollie Wright	1st
2019-20	Men's Tennis	Jeremiah Sanchez (Doubles)	1st
2019-20	Men's Tennis	Brendan Brown (Doubles)	1st
2019-20	Women's Tennis	Ashley Penshorn (Singles)	1st
2019-20	Women's Tennis	Ashley Penshorn (Doubles)	1st
2019-20	Women's Tennis	Marina Vigil (Doubles)	1st

*All-Americans from 1960-1999 were affiliated with the NAIA. All-Americans from 2001-present are affiliated with NCAA Division II. 

ALL-AMERICANS BY SPORT
Baseball: 46
Men's Basketball: 40
Men's Golf: 10
Men's Soccer: 6
Men's Tennis: 5
Softball: 49
Volleyball: 10
Women's Basketball: 12
Women's Golf: 3
Women's Soccer: 3
Women's Tennis: 6
Total: 200

ALL-AMERICANS BY DECADE
1960s: 9
1970s: 18
1980s: 29
1990s: 63
2000s: 36
2010s: 46

ALL-AMERICANS BY DIVISION
NAIA: 119
NCAA Division II: 82